- Ensenada's previous mayor left office mid-term to run for Senate and faces demands for impeachment over a reported 3.6 billion peso pension fund debt. He is now a senator reportedly eyeing the governorship.
- The current mayor runs a prolific press release machine crediting herself for federal programs, national holidays, and the weather. Garbage pickup runs every two to three weeks in many colonias. She says 9 out of 10 homes have permanent service.
- The city's Sindicatura (internal auditor) said a 13.5 million peso garbage truck rental debt had no legal basis. Cabildo paid it anyway, to a company linked to a federal political figure.
- Road repairs get done badly, slowly, and only until the first rain — because doing them right means there's no follow-up contract.
- The tourist waterfront is genuinely lovely. The rest is a different city.
Ensenada is beautiful. I mean that sincerely. The bay at dusk, the wine country an hour inland, the fog rolling in off the Pacific in the morning — this is one of the more visually stunning places I’ve lived, and I’ve lived in a lot of places. Tourists who come for the cruise port or the weekend wine run get the genuine article.
They also get clean streets, intact sidewalks, working streetlights, and the version of Ensenada that the municipal government actually maintains. That Ensenada is real too.
The rest of the city is something else. The colonias beyond the tourist corridor run on private water deliveries, intermittent trash pickup, and roads patched badly and repeatedly because doing them right would end the contract. This is the Ensenada the people who live here actually inhabit. And it is governed — if that’s the word — by a municipal government that has made an art form of doing the minimum while claiming credit for everything.
We have two mayors to work with. Together they span roughly a decade of Ensenada municipal governance. They are different people with different styles and different scandals. What they share is an absolute mastery of the press release and an equally absolute indifference to garbage collection.
Armándolos Juntos: Building What, Exactly?
Armando Ayala Robles served as Ensenada’s mayor not once but twice — most recently from 2019 to early 2024, when he resigned mid-term to run for Senate with Morena. He won. He’s now a senator for Baja California and reportedly has his eye on the governorship in 2027.
His slogan during his mayoral tenure was “Armándolos Juntos.” Building it together. The city installed branded stickers with that slogan on the municipal trash cans. This is useful context.
In April 2025, the PAN bloc in the Baja California legislature filed for Ayala’s political impeachment over a reported 3.6 billion peso debt to ISSSTECALI (Instituto de Seguridad y Servicios Sociales de los Trabajadores del Estado de Baja California — the state pension and health fund covering municipal workers). The allegation: his administration deducted contributions from workers’ paychecks and never forwarded them to the fund. Classic.
His response was to call it politically motivated and to note that he’d paid more toward the ISSSTECALI debt than any previous mayor. He didn’t deny the 3.6 billion. He just said it was there before him. He said this as someone who had been mayor twice.
The ISSSTECALI debt, in full
ISSSTECALI functions like a state-level version of IMSS (Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social — Mexico's federal social security system) specifically for Baja California municipal and state employees. It covers health care, pensions, and retirement. Employers — in this case the municipal government — are legally required to remit matching contributions alongside the amounts deducted from employee pay.
The PAN impeachment filing, covered by Semanario ZETA and Newsweek Español in April 2025, alleged that Ayala's administrations deducted contributions from workers' paychecks but failed to remit them to ISSSTECALI — leaving workers believing they had pension coverage while the money went elsewhere. The reported shortfall: 3,600 million pesos.
Ayala's defense: the debt predated him, it was a structural problem across administrations, and he'd contributed approximately 800 million pesos toward it — more than any predecessor. None of that math addresses 3.6 billion. If the impeachment process moves forward, it could result in a political ban from office of six months to twenty years. As of early 2026 he remains a sitting senator.
It gets more colorful. In February 2024, right as Ayala was preparing to resign to run for Senate, a video circulated on Mexican social media showing an alleged Sinaloa Cartel member — kneeling, hooded, being interrogated — claiming that a cousin of Ayala’s operated as a cartel intermediary in Ensenada, that Ayala had met with cartel leadership, and that he “needed their economic support” for his political ambitions. Ayala denied all of it and attributed the video to electoral dirty tricks.
On the cartel video allegations
The February 2024 video was reported nationally by Infobae. The person making the allegations identified himself as an alleged Sinaloa Cartel member operating in Ensenada. He named a cousin of Ayala's, identified as "El Poyo Ayala," as an intermediary. He claimed Ayala had met with cartel bosses and sought their financial backing for his political career.
Ayala denied every element publicly and stated he was filing legal complaints for defamation. The allegations come from a person who is himself a self-identified cartel member, in a coerced interrogation video — not a sworn deposition. They have not been substantiated by any judicial proceeding as of this writing.
What is documentable: Ayala's administration had a consistent record of corruption allegations from local journalists and political opponents throughout his tenure. The broader context of organized crime influence in Baja California port cities is well-established, though that says nothing specific about any individual official.
The voters of Baja California rewarded this record with a Senate seat. He is, by all indications, planning to run for governor.
The trash cans with “Armándolos Juntos” stickers are still out there. I see them regularly.
The Press Release Mayor
Claudia Agatón became Ensenada’s first female mayor in October 2024. Her administration posts to Facebook several times per day. Every post names her in the first sentence. Most credit her personally for things she had nothing to do with.
This is not a wild accusation. It’s just what the page shows.
The Ensenada Ballet Folklórico performed at Mexico Week in Chicago. “Our mayor Claudia Agatón celebrated…” The NORRA off-road race brought 20,000 visitors and 60 million pesos in economic activity. “Our mayor Claudia Agatón announced…” It was Día del Niño, and children in Maneadero ate cake. “Our mayor Claudia Agatón…” Federal president Sheinbaum announced a 5.7 billion peso port investment. “Our mayor Claudia Agatón celebrates…” She watched a soccer kick-off. Post. Published. Done.
This is a coherent political communication strategy and it works for a certain voter base. But it creates a specific cognitive dissonance for anyone who lives in a colonia more than three blocks from the waterfront.
What the Facebook page says she does
- Celebrates the Ballet Folklórico at national events
- Attends military commemorations (via proxy)
- Announces federal port investments
- Hosts Día del Niño parties for 2,000 kids
- Coordinates a meeting about organizing a future meeting about Infonavit
- Achieved "historic" garbage collection coverage
What municipal government actually controls
- Garbage collection
- Local roads and potholes
- Municipal police
- Building permits and zoning
- Street lighting
- Local parks and public spaces
Notice the overlap between those two lists. It’s small.
Here’s what I’d actually like to see from Ensenada’s first female mayor: results in the column on the right. Being first matters — it’s genuinely historic. But “first” only means something if it comes with actual governance. The constant reminder lands differently when the garbage doesn’t run on schedule. What this city needs isn’t more photo ops and broken commitments. We need some “bitches get shit done” energy applied to the things the municipal government is actually responsible for.
The Garbage Situation
Let me tell you about the garbage.
Agatón’s administration let the existing trash contract expire without quickly running a new competitive bidding process. The contractor kept operating without a valid agreement. Pickup in many colonias slowed from weekly to every two to three weeks — or stopped entirely.
The city then rented 18 garbage trucks from a private company. No bidding process. No valid contract. By July 2025, the city owed 13.5 million pesos to this company. Infobae reporting identified the owner as Luis Humberto Montaño, described as a collaborator of Morena federal politician Adán Augusto López.
The Sindicatura Municipal — the city’s internal auditing body — reviewed it and said clearly: there is no legal basis for this debt. The Tesorería (Treasury) confirmed no payments had been processed during the period in question. Legally, the city owed nothing.
Cabildo voted to pay it anyway on July 15, 2025. Agatón voted yes.
Meanwhile, her October 2025 annual report claimed nine out of ten Ensenada homes now had permanent, reliable garbage service. A “historic achievement,” she called it.
In many colonias, the reality looks like this: bags sit on the corner for two or three weeks. Informal scavengers — people sorting trash for anything sellable — go through them first, scattering what they don’t want. Dogs do the same. By the time the truck eventually shows up, what started as a bag is now a dispersed mess across ten meters of sidewalk.
Private residential collection exists. It runs around 300 pesos per pickup. Mexico’s daily minimum wage is approximately 400 pesos. For most families in a working-class colonia, that math doesn’t work. So trash sits.
The city’s official response to citizens experiencing missed pickup: check the Facebook page for the daily route schedule, and text the WhatsApp number if there’s a problem.
The Roads
The roads in Ensenada’s tourist corridor are fine. Smooth concrete, good signage, maintained regularly. Drive three colonias inland and you’ll find pavement that looks like a war zone that lost.
I’ve lived on the same street since I moved to Ensenada. It has been a mess the entire time. At some point, the neighbors organized — that collective ritual where everyone debates for weeks, some refuse to participate, and eventually whoever can afford it kicks in. We all went down to the Casa Municipal and paid 8,000 pesos each to CUME (Consejo de Urbanización Municipal de Ensenada — the Municipal Urbanization Council, the office responsible for neighborhood-funded infrastructure projects) under the programa por cooperación, a mechanism where residents contribute a share and the city does the work.
Eight thousand pesos. For many of my neighbors, that’s close to a month’s wages. Getting everyone to contribute was hard. Some genuinely didn’t have it.
The city took the money. Six months passed. CUME did nothing. The street was not repaired.
We had to make the trip back to the municipal building — another tramite — to get the money back. Except they didn’t have it. We waited until the next fiscal year, when predial (property tax) revenues came in, to get our refunds. Two tramites. Months of float time. Eight thousand pesos per household tied up. For nothing.
Fast forward three years. The city eventually came out and paved the two cross streets in the colonia. Not the ones running perpendicular — those are still mostly disintegrated — just the cross streets. So every time it rains, mud from the dirt connecting streets washes straight across the brand-new concrete. The new cross streets look barely distinguishable from the unpaved ones.
Why road repairs keep failing: the structural incentive
Mexican municipal road contracting generally works through licitación — competitive bidding. In practice, contracts in smaller municipalities often go to politically connected companies, as local investigations have documented repeatedly in Ensenada.
The incentive structure is perverse. A contractor who builds to proper depth with correct drainage creates infrastructure that lasts five to ten years — and generates no follow-up contracts. A contractor who builds to lower spec, but passes municipal inspection, creates infrastructure that fails within one or two rainy seasons. The city pays twice. The contractor profits twice. Someone in the approval chain benefits either way.
This isn't unique to Ensenada. It's a documented pattern in Mexican municipal public works contracting at all levels. The Ramo 33 fund — federal budget allocation specifically for municipal capital works like roads and drainage — is the one Agatón's administration is currently under state investigation for allegedly manipulating. Her own Director of Bienestar Social filed the complaint.
The April 2025 concrete resurfacing project on Calle Mina, per the city's own post, was poured at 7.5 centimeter thickness. Standard residential street specification is typically 15 centimeters minimum. Three inches of concrete is not a road. It's a gesture toward a road.
The branded city vehicles and the police escort motorcade are in excellent condition, for what it’s worth. The mayor travels with sirens and a black SUV escort. Most mayors of genuinely well-run cities don’t operate like that. Ensenada’s does.
What Mexican Municipal Government Actually Controls
This matters for expats, especially new arrivals who assume the mayor runs the city the way an American mayor does.
She doesn’t. The federal-state-municipal structure in Mexico means most of the services you care about aren’t municipal at all.
| Service | Who controls it | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Garbage collection | Municipal | Fully the mayor's problem. See above. |
| Local roads (city streets) | Municipal | Municipal, with federal Ramo 33 funding for capital projects. |
| State highways (Mex 3, Mex 1) | State / Federal | Not the mayor's department. |
| Water and sewer | CESPE | CESPE (Comisión Estatal de Servicios Públicos de Ensenada — the state water and sewer utility) operates semi-independently of municipal government. |
| Electricity | CFE (federal) | CFE (Comisión Federal de Electricidad) is completely federal. The mayor has zero input here. |
| Police | Municipal + State | Municipal police handle local enforcement. State police operate separately. |
| Healthcare | Federal (IMSS, IMSS-Bienestar, ISSSTE) | IMSS (Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social) and related federal programs. The mayor can coordinate, not control. |
| Housing programs (Infonavit) | Federal | Infonavit (Instituto del Fondo Nacional de la Vivienda para los Trabajadores — the federal workers' housing fund) is run from Mexico City. The mayor can attend the meeting about a future meeting. That's about it. |
| Building permits, zoning | Municipal | Slow, expensive, and frequently subject to complaint. |
| Street lighting | Municipal | The mayor can legitimately take credit for streetlights. Many don't work. |
The tourist waterfront gets maintained because it’s a revenue-generating zone the city has economic interest in keeping presentable. Cruise ships come in. Wine tourists come through. The restaurants, bars, and fish taco spots along the malecón pay taxes and generate political goodwill.
The colonias three kilometers inland don’t have a lobby.
The Deeper Problem
An ex of mine — Mexican, grew up here — told me something I’ve thought about since: this is an improvement. The pre-Ayala Ensenada was worse.
I’m choosing to believe him, because the alternative is too depressing.
The real issue isn’t incompetence, though there’s plenty. It’s that the incentive structure of Mexican municipal politics actively rewards specific behaviors. Win an election. Take credit for federal programs. Run contracting processes that benefit connected parties. Generate a constant stream of visible activity on social media. Move on before accountability arrives.
Ayala turned two mayoral terms into a Senate seat and a likely gubernatorial run, all while facing impeachment demands over pension debts and a video linking him — however unverified — to organized crime. The voters promoted him.
Agatón posts five times a day about garbage service that isn’t running on schedule across significant parts of the city. She was mentioned in a national presidential press conference over an alleged tow truck corruption scheme. Her administration is under state investigation for Ramo 33 fund irregularities. Her own Director of Bienestar Social filed the complaint against her. The Facebook page celebrated “historic” trash pickup rates the same month residents in Las Peñitas were asked to haul their junk to the curb on a specific Saturday so a special crew could come — as a favor, not a standard service.
This is what governing looks like when governance is primarily a PR problem.
Leave a comment